Social Workers. Help Starts Here. Help Starts Here Collage
 
     
Archive for the ‘ Current Trends ’ Category

Healthy Parenting Current Trends — All Children Matter: How Legal and Social Inequalities Hurt LGBT Families

October 25, 2011

All Children Matter

All Children Matter Study

A newly released research report, All Children Matter: How Legal and Social Inequalities Hurt LGBT Families is the most comprehensive look to date at children living in LGBT families—and how they are failed by society, government and the law.   Co-authored by the Movement Advancement Project, the Family Equality Council, and the Center for American Progress, the report shares the challenges faced by the two million children raised by LGBT parents—children from all walks of life, living in almost every U.S. county. The 100+ recommendations included in the report are focused on enacting simple changes to unfair laws and policies to ensure that all children have the chance to reach their full potential.   Report partners also include the Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute, the National Association of Social Workers, and COLAGE.

Remarked, Dr. Jean W. Anastas, NASW president, “NASW is pleased to be a partner on this report.   The key findings of the report highlight the laws, policies and practices that perpetuate inequalities experienced by LGBT families.     Social workers address the needs of all types of families in our diverse society and work toward eliminating stigma, harassment and discrimination directed at LGBT people and their families.   The report recommendations are in alignment with the values and ethics of the social work profession, and are supported by the guidance reflected in the NASW "Social Work Speaks" policy statements".

The report is available at www.children-matter.org.

To see more of NASW’s LGBT reports and Practice Updates, please click here.

To find a social worker in your area, please click here.

Obsessions and Compulsions: Current Trends – Asperger’s Syndrome Q&A With William Shryer, DCSW, LCSW

Introduction

William Shryer is the Clinical Director of Diablo Behavioral Health Care in Danville, CA.   Mr. Shryer earned his BA degree in Sociology at California State University in Hayward. He received his MSW from the University of California at Berkeley specializing in Children and Families. Mr. Shryer has been in private practice since 1981 specializing in Autistic Spectrum Disorders, Mood Disorders, and the Anxiety Spectrum in children, adults and their families. Mr. Shryer has lectured frequently to college classes and professionals in the areas of ADD and Autistic Spectrum disorders and their implications in the educational setting. He has been active in a number of CHADD chapters. Mr. Shryer manages three behavioral clinics with a staff of MD’s, Counselors, Clinical Psychologists, and Special Education teachers. He has been the moderator on CCTV, (Contra Costa Television) for both “Mental Health Perspectives”, and “With the Family in Mind” which discussed topics such as Asperger’s Disorder, Autism, Bipolar disorder and Attention Deficit Disorder in children and adults.


Q.               What is Asperger's syndrome and how is it different from ADHD?  

Asperger's Syndrome is a variant of autism therefore on the autism spectrum.   While it is indeed possible to have ADHD and Asperger's it is often misdiagnosed as ADHD by those clinically unfamiliar with Asperger's.   A central difference between Asperger's and ADHD is that the individual with ADHD has a neurobiological difficulty in focusing and paying attention, therefore an Attention Deficit Disorder, while an individual with Asperger's will have difficulty deciding on what to pay attention to, or not be able to shift attention from what they want to think about to what someone else wants them to think about.   When misdiagnosed as ADHD the individual with Asperger's will often be prescribed the medications to treat ADHD and have their internal anxiety state go to into high gear.   If they have stuck thoughts the stimulant medications can increase their stuckness so now they have what I call "Attention Surplus Disorder".   The higher functioning the individual with Asperger's may be the more likely they are to be misdiagnosed by the uninformed.

Q.               Does it affect more boys than girls?  

Asperger's was thought to affect more boys than girls by a wide margin; however this is being called into question lately.   While the number of boys referred for evaluation is around 10:1, it now appears that girls are more likely to present very differently than boys.   Girls are more likely to give aid and support to an "Aspie" peer while boys are more likely to be bullied and made fun of.   With so many of our diagnostic categories' it seems that girls present differently and therefore are missed, or misdiagnosed.

Q.               What are the typical behavioral manifestations?   Their talents, their shortcomings?  

The behavioral manifestations vary depending on age and severity of the disorder.   Younger children and more often boys than girls will be very concrete in their interpretations of things asked of them.   They often have an odd quality to their speech patterns often speaking in a pedantic, "little professor" manner.   They are famous for starting an answer with, "actually".   They have real difficulty with social nuance and the unwritten rules of social discourse.   They often don't get what comes naturally to other children, they make talk too loud or too quiet, and they may stand too close to someone or too far away.   They often have great difficulty with ADL's or activities of daily living such as teeth brushing, hair combing and other issues related to hygiene making them easy prey for targeting.   Eye contact is often difficult for them and much more common in boys than girls.   It seems girls with Asperger's are better at watching and copying the behavior of other girls in order to appear to fit in.   As far as their talents go, they are often very intelligent as the so often have a parent that is a engineer or some other occupation that requires high intelligence.   Since they have a very concrete way of perceiving the world they often do poorly at algebra but can be a whiz at calculus or trigonometry.   They often have great skills in the computer area and as kids love computer games as they are not played with others directly.   

Q.               What kind of   partners / spouses are they?  

I have seen several who are in fact married and it always seems to be an Aspie man married to a non-aspie woman.   Maybe it's the idea of some women that they can change the man or nurture them so they will change.   Often the woman married to an aspie man needs to learn proper expectations of their spouse.   Remembering birthdays and to say kind things in a relationship are important and the individual with Asperger's will have to be taught these things as they will not come naturally to them.   In the movie Adam, which is a wonderful movie about Asperger's and relationships the woman in the show says to Adam, "Can I have a hug?" Adam responds with, "yes" and then does nothing.   The woman realizing he was being concrete say to Adam, "Can I have a hug Now" and receives one.   This is a great example of how they handle intimacy.

Q.               How were these young people diagnosed in the past?  

In the past most young people with Asperger's were misdiagnosed.   Some of the more common misdiagnoses were ADHD, Obsessive Compulsive Disorder even though most with Asperger's stuck on their own particular fascination, be it vacuum cleaners, algae, dinosaurs, or medieval history show little to no anxiety while thinking about their special area.   The anxiety that these folks feel is in relation to knowing on some level that they don't know how to navigate the social landscape.   They have been misdiagnosed as schizophrenia, schizotypal personality disorder, avoidant personality disorder, obsessive compulsive personality disorder, even antisocial personality disorder.   When these poor young people that fell into the grasp of poorly trained clinicians it gives new meaning to the old saying that if "all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail". The professionals that saw them didn't know about Asperger's so they tried to fit them into categories they did know to the misfortune of many children and teens over the years.

Q.              How can therapy help them?  

The reality is that typical therapy really doesn't help them.  The abstract world of "How does that make you feel" is beyond them.   They frustrate most clinicians that don't know the patient they have is Asperger's.   They need a lot of direction and coaching and training.   While what I do I call therapy with this group, it is highly directed, very structured and involves the entire family, the school and often other groups.   Assisting the schools to provide the support they need is central for them as well.   Often the schools and the parents are overwhelmed with the often odd and perservative behavior they can demonstrate.   This is one diagnostic category where the saying, "It takes a village" was never more true.

###

To find a social worker in your area, please click here.

Dr. Caitlin Ryan and The Family Acceptance Projects’ Studies of LGBT Youth

Dr. Caitlin Ryan, Director of the Family Acceptance Project at San Francisco State University

School Bullying, Violence Against Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual & Transgender Youth Linked With Risk for Suicide, HIV and STDs in Young Adulthood

MAY 16, 2011 – Critical new research has found that lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) youth who experience high levels of school victimization in middle and high school report impaired health and mental health in young adulthood, including depression, suicide attempts that require medical care, sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) and risk for HIV. This is the first known study to examine the relationship between school victimization during adolescence – specifically related to sexual orientation and gender identity – with multiple dimensions of young adult health and adjustment. The study demonstrates the importance of addressing and preventing anti-LGBT victimization at the structural or school level to reduce health disparities among LGBT young people.   The study is published in the Journal of School Health, the journal of the American School Health Association.

Analyzing data from the Family Acceptance Project's young adult survey, the authors examined experiences related to school victimization during adolescence based on known or perceived LGBT identity among 245 LGBT young adults, ages 21 to 25. They found that LGBT young adults who were victimized in school because of their LGBT identity reported much higher health and adjustment problems, while students with low levels of school victimization had higher self-esteem and life satisfaction as young adults.

Key Research Findings:

  • LGBT young adults who reported high levels of LGBT school victimization during adolescence were 5.6 times more likely to report having attempted suicide, 5.6 times more likely to report a suicide attempt that required medical care, 2.6 times more likely to report clinical levels of depression, 2.5 times more likely to have been diagnosed with a sexually transmitted disease, and nearly 4 times more likely to report risk for HIV infection, compared with peers who reported low levels of school victimization.
  • Gay and bisexual males and transgender young adults reported higher levels of LGBT school victimization than lesbian and bisexual young women.
  • LGBT young adults who reported lower levels of school victimization reported higher levels of self-esteem, life satisfaction and social integration compared with peers with higher levels of school victimization during adolescence.

To book an interview with the authors or for a copy of the full paper, please contact cathy@rennacommunications.com

December 13, 2010 – NASW Member Dr. Caitlin Ryan, Director of the San Francisco based Family Acceptance  Project,  has released a study that found that accepting parental and caregiver behaviors — such as welcoming their children's openly LGBT friends or supporting their gender expression — protect their LGBT children against depression, substance abuse, suicidal thoughts and suicide attempts in early adulthood. In addition, LGBT youth with highly accepting families have significantly higher levels of self-esteem, social support and better overall health in young adulthood.

The study was published in the November 2010 issue of the international Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Nursing. This follows Dr. Ryan's study published in Developmental Psychology  in the same month which shows that LGBT young adults who do not conform to socially proscribed gender behavior as adolescents report higher levels of anti-LGBT victimization, and higher levels of depression and impaired life satisfaction in adulthood.   Dr. Ryan's research has generated a substantial  level of consumer media coverage.

  • To read the press release from Renna Communications, click here.
  • To read the study, click here.
  • To learn more about the Family Acceptance Project, click here.  

Dr. Ryan is a member of the Institute of Medicine committee that created a landmark publication released on March 31, 2011,  on LGBT health.   Click here to learn more about the study


Media Coverage  

Ladies Home Journal.com
1.8 million unique visitors per month
Gay Teens Versus Traditional Family

TIME.com
7.6 million unique visitors per month
The Protective Effect of Family Acceptance for Gay Teens

Businessweek.com
5.2 million unique visitors per month
Parents' acceptance may help protect gay teens

Science Daily
1.1 million unique visitors per month
Family Acceptance of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Youth Protects Against Depression, Substance Abuse, Suicide, Study Suggests

Salt Lake Tribune
639,549 unique visitors per month
Guidance for LDS families with LBGT children – Op-Ed

Advocate.com
187,791 unique visitors per month
All in the Family – Commentary  by Judy Shepard, mother of the late Matthew Shepard

ABC News  .com
9.4 million unique visitors per month
Family Support for Gay Teens Saves Lives

LiveScience.com
1.1 million unique visitors per month
Accepting Parents Boost Mental Health of LGBT Teens

WEbMD.com
12.5 million unique visitors per month
Lesbian/Gay/Bi Teens Punished More

Change.org

Family Acceptance Key to LGBT Youth Well-Being

CNN.com
25 million unique visitors per month
For LGBT teens, acceptance is critical

Edge Gay Media Network
123,183 unique visitors per month
Study Details How Family’s Acceptance Protects LGBT Youth

Mombian.com
What Helps LGBT Youth? Family Acceptance

ColorLines:   News for Action
Circulation: 30,000
Parenting Queer Youth and Saving Their Lives

###

To find a social worker in your area, please click here.

Caregiving Current Trends – NASW Releases Standards for Social Work Practice with Family Caregivers of Older Adults

November 2010

NASW is pleased to announce the release of its new Standards for Social Work Practice with Family Caregivers of Older Adults. The NASW standards enhance social work practice with family caregivers and help the public understand how social workers support family caregivers.

The release of the standards coincides with National Family Caregivers Month and the launch of the U.S. Administration on Aging's Year of the Caregiver.

Social workers understand that family caregivers play an important role in supporting older adults. They also understand that family caregivers do not always get the recognition they deserve or the support they need.

Social workers meet and help family caregivers in many places:  

  • Health care settings such as hospitals, clinics, and nursing homes
  • Social service agencies for families and older adults
  • Mental health settings
  • Employee assistance and eldercare programs
  • Agencies serving veterans and active military
  • Housing programs and faith-based organizations  

Professional social workers have a bachelor's or master's degree in social work and complete many hours of supervised fieldwork as part of their education. Social workers follow a Code of Ethics and know how to work well with people of all cultures. Many social workers have years of experience working with family caregivers of older adults. Social workers provide many important services to family caregivers:  

  • Educating caregivers about aging, health, and mental health
  • Counseling to help families cope with the stresses of caregiving
  • Coordinating care and services
  • Linking caregivers with the resources they need
  • Helping families plan for the future
  • Leading support groups for family caregivers
  • Working through conflicts and managing crises
  • Advocating to help families reach their goals
  • Communicating with other service providers and organizations
  • Helping families find their way through transitions  
Social workers help family caregivers take care of themselves.    
  • Click here to read the NASW Standards for Family Caregivers of Older Adults.
  • Click here to find a social worker in your community with expertise in aging or other areas.
  • Click here to learn more about caregiving and aging.
  • Click here to find out how you can get involved in National Family Caregivers Month.
  • Click here to learn about the Year of the Caregiver and the Administration on Aging.

Development of the NASW Standards for Social Work Practice with Family Caregivers of Older Adults is part of Professional Partners Supporting Family Caregivers, an initiative done in partnership with the AARP Foundation, the U.S. Administration on Aging, the Family Caregiver Alliance, and the National Association of Social Workers, and made possible by funding from the John A. Hartford Foundation

###

Tendencias actuales de paternidad saludable – Los niños como intérpretes: ¿Quién tiene el poder cuando slo los niños hablan inglés?

Maribel Quiala es una psicoterapeuta / trabajadora social clinica cuya experiencia en salud mental y desordenes psiquiatricos y familias dirigida a las latinas/o in estados Unidos. Ella es la coordinadora regional en Washington DC de la Red Nacional de la Salud de las Mujeras Latinas (NLHN) Y miembro de decenas de organizaciones que favorecen a las hispana.

Nota a los reporteros: Si van a usar parte del texto de  Maribel Quiala, por favor identifíquenla como miembro de la Asociación Nacional  de  Trabajadores Sociales.

El poder del idioma en la Dinámica de la Familia Latina

Los niños de familias latinas son a menudo el único medio de comunicacin con el mundo Anglo-americano. Aunque a primera vista esto podría parecer una solucin práctica e incluso razonable, hacer al niño excesivamente responsable de la comunicacin de un adulto puede alterar la dinámica familiar. Es necesario un equilibrio adecuado de poder para que cualquier familia funcione efectivamente.

Inicialmente, se le pide a menudo a los niños que interpreten para sus padres, sin un impacto serio en la estructura de la familia o integridad de la informacin. Sin embargo, a medida que el tiempo pasa, este no es siempre el caso.

Los estudios demuestran que algunos proveedores de cuidados de salud no tienen opcin pero confían en personal bilingüe no entrenado, amigos y miembros de la familia, mucha veces niños, para proveer informacin crítica y a menudo muy privada. El tener un niño intérprete para un padre sobre temas sexuales y o abuso marital puede colocar una presin y responsabilidad indebida sobre el niño.

Un cambio en el Equilibrio de Poder

También, cuando un niño es la única fuente de interpretacin de informacin educativa a un padre sobre ellos mismos, en un evento de puertas abiertas, conferencia o reunin de padres/maestros, se crea el escenario para que el equilibrio de poder nuevamente esté inadecuadamente distribuido. Incluso en el ambiente escolar, podrían omitir informacin crítica y/o alterar el contenido a su ventaja.

Un niño que tiene que interpretar informacin de salud sensible en nombre de un miembro de la familia es tan malo como hacer que el niño sea el mensajero para decirle a sus padres que la escuela está por expulsarlo debido a mala conducta o hacerlo repetir de grado debido a su mal desempeño académico.

Muchos inmigrantes Hispanos/Latinos están bajo la utilizacin de servicios de cuidados de salud públicos. Son reacios debido a que no tienen informacin acerca de los servicios para hacerlo. Muchas veces no participan en las actividades escolares de sus hijos debido a la vergüenza por las barreras del idioma y la incapacidad para navegar en el sistema educativo. Aunque desean estar más involucrados en la educacin de sus hijos a menudo enfrentan obstáculos debido a sus limitadas capacidades de Inglés.   Los ya sobrecargados sistemas escolares podrían no tener los recursos para proveer un número adecuado de personal bilingüe.

 ¿Informacin adecuada para su edad?

No siempre es aconsejable tener niños como intérpretes para sus padres, debido a que un niño no debería estar interpretando informacin no adecuada a su edad o ser puesto en posicin de poder manipular el proceso de interpretacin para su propio beneficio.

Cuando los niños inadvertidamente se transforman en la cabeza familiar simplemente porque hablan el idioma, terminan controlando todos los tipos de comunicacin que pueden afectar adversamente los roles y relaciones familiares. Los padres podrían realmente transformarse en inferiores y a medida que los niños crecen, si los padres no aprenden a hablar Inglés, la co-dependencia puede abarcar generaciones.

Idealmente, los niños deberían ver a sus padres por consejo, guía, direccin, seguridad e informacin —  ¡no en el otro sentido!

###

The National Association of Social Workers (NASW), en Washington, D.C., es la más extensa organizacin de trabajadores sociales profesionales en el mundo con cerca de 150.000 miembros con 56 delegaciones a lo largo de los Estados Unidos y sus territorios. Promueve, desarrolla, y protege la práctica del trabajo social y de los trabajadores sociales. NASW también busca mejorar el bienestar de los individuos, familias y comunidades a través de la asistencia.

Healthy Parenting Current Trends – Children as Interpreters:Who Has the Power When Only the Kids Speak English?

The Power of Language in the Latino Family Dynamic

Children of Latino families are often the only means of communicating with the Anglo world.   Although on the surface this may appear to be a practical, even reasonable solution, making a child overly responsible for an adult's communication can alter the family dynamic.   An appropriate balance of power is necessary for any family to function effectively.  

Initially, children are often asked to interpret for their parents, with no serious impact to the family structure or integrity of information.   However, as time goes on, this is not always the case.  

Studies demonstrate that some health care providers have no choice but to rely on untrained bilingual staff, friends and family members, many times children, to provide critical and often very private information.   Having a child interpret for a parent about sexual matters and or spousal abuse can place undue pressure and responsibility on a child.

A Shift in the Power Balance

Also, when children are the only source interpreting educational information to a parent about themselves, at an open house, conference or parent/teacher meeting, the stage is set for the balance of power to again be inappropriately distributed.   Even in a school setting, they might omit critical information and/or alter the content to their advantage.

A child having to interpret sensitive health information on behalf of a family member is just as bad as making the child the messenger for telling their parent(s) that the school is about to expel them due to bad conduct or hold them back a grade due to poor academic performance.

Many Hispanics/Latina immigrants are under utilizing public health care services. They are reluctant because they lack information about the services to do so.   Many times they do not participate in their children's school activities because of embarrassment due to language barriers and inability to navigate the educational system.   Even though they want to be more involved in their children’s education they often face obstacles due to their limited English skills.   Already overburdened school systems may not have the resources to provide a proportionate number of bilingual personnel.

Age- Appropriate Information?

It is not always advisable to have  children interpret for their parents, because a child should not be interpreting non age-appropriate information or be put in the position of being able to manipulate the interpreting process for their own benefit.  

When children inadvertently become the heads of households simply because they speak the language, they end up controlling all types of communication that can adversely affect family roles and relationships.   The parents may actually become inferior and as the child gets older, if parents do not learn to speak English, the co-dependency can span generations.  

Ideally, kids should be looking up to their parents for advice, guidance, direction, security and   clarification — not the other way around!

###

Related Articles:

Obsessions and Compulsions Current Trends

Obsessions and Compulsions Current Trends – Compulsive Hoarding Q&A

Introduction

Gail Steketee, PhD is  the Dean of the Boston University School Social Work. Her recent research, funded by the National Institute of Mental Health, focuses on diagnostic and personality aspects of compulsive hoarding and on effective treatments. She and  Randy O. Frost, PhD, of the Smith College School of Psychology are  co-authors of the book Stuff: Compulsive Hoarding and the Meaning of Things  published in 2010.


Q. Dr. Steketee, what is the average age of a person who hoards? Is it mostly senior citizens who remember The Great Depression and now can't bring themselves to throw anything away?   Also, is there an average age of onset or some sort of mental tipping point?

Hoarding begins in adolescence and becomes a significant problem for most people in their 30's. However, the average age of people seeking treatment is about 50, ranging mainly from early 40s’ to elderly adults. Although many people who hoard are over 65, most did not experience deprivation such as that from the Great Depression, so this does not appear to be a major cause of hoarding. On the other hand, we have some evidence that people who hoard may experience more disruptions early in life (one example is moving frequently as a child). Perhaps these experiences lead them to trust people less than the objects around them.

Q. How does this disorder breakdown by gender?

Epidemiological studies indicate that hoarding occurs more often in men than women, but treatment seekers are mainly women. This suggests that men are less likely to seek help. We are not sure if they are less likely to recognize that they have a problem or just less interested in treatment.

Q. What is the difference between someone who hoards common objects versus someone who has, for example,  40 cats in their home?

We don't really know the answer to this question. We know quite a bit about hoarding of objects, but rather little about people who collect and do not take adequate care of animals. However, we have some evidence that animal hoarding may stem from a failure to develop strong attachment to people early in life and a higher frequency of stressful life events during childhood. These factors might contribute to limited ability to cope effectively with adverse personal situations in childhood and later on in adulthood so they don't function well in work and social activities during adulthood.  Therefore, they turn to animals for unconditional love and support.

Q. Can hoarders be good spouses and parents?   Can they devote their time and attention to relationships?

It is true that people who hoard tend to live alone and not to marry more than other people, but many do maintain strong relationships with others. However, as many children of hoarders can attest, some (but by no means all) parents who hoard do not attend as closely as they should to the developmental needs of their children (e.g., for play space alone and with friends) and other social needs.

Q. What is involved in treating these patients and how long does therapy last typically?

We have developed a reasonably effective cognitive and behavioral treatment for hoarding and have published a therapy guide and client workbook on this topic with Oxford University Press. This treatment uses 26 sessions that can be delivered in a combination of office and home visits; group treatment is also an option. Treatment takes 6-12 months (and sometimes more for severe clutter) and includes motivational strategies to overcome ambivalence about discarding and not acquiring items, skills training for organizing and decision-making, cognitive therapy to change faulty thinking, and extensive practice reducing excessive clutter and acquiring.   We are continuing to seeks ways to improve the outcomes of this treatment which leaves about 75 percent  of people who complete it feeling much or very much improved

Please click here to see images of compulsive hoarding provided by the  International OCD Foundation.

###

Related Articles:

Addictions – Current Trends: Mental Illness and Substance Abuse: The Connection

By Susan Klein Winston, LCSW-R

   Introduction
   Self Medicating Behavior
   Abstinence from Drugs and Alcohol
   Dual Disorders
Introduction

Many  of us have experienced people in our lives that have had some form of mental illness, and or substance abuse. These problems can range from mild symptoms with little impairment noted to  severe psychiatric, behavioral and social consequences.

Those who experience emotional and psychiatric conditions can benefit from various types of  talk therapy  and medication treatments designed to target their specific problem. Medications for psychiatric conditions are usually prescribed by a psychiatrist who specializes in pharmacology for symptoms associated with these conditions. Some of these conditions include anxiety, depression, phobias, PTSD, (Post traumatic stress Disorder), bipolar disorder and other serious illnesses such as schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder.

Self Medicating Behavior

At times, manifestations of these illnesses are so intolerable to the sufferer that relief is found through the use and abuse of alcohol, prescription and illicit drugs. This is sometimes referred to as “Self medicating behavior”. While the individual may be seeking relief or attempting to just “feel better”, the person actually is attempting to obtain biological or chemical symptom relief in the absence of medically supervised intervention.

Sometimes social drinking” or “recreational” drug use can develop into more serious dependency or addictive patterns of behavior. This alone can contribute to maladaptive coping mechanisms and problems with family, work and daily functioning. The biological effects of substances can also contribute to mood instability causing psychiatric symptoms, or exacerbate an already existing mental illness.

The majority of treatment services have traditionally been divided into specialized services, one for mental health or psychiatric illness, and another for those experiencing drug and alcohol abuse or dependency. Unfortunately this distinction and splitting of treatment services doesn't always meet the needs of persons suffering from both disorders.

Abstinence from Drugs and Alcohol

Many substance abuse specialists embrace the philosophy that people must establish complete abstinence from substance in order to achieve their goals. In addition, refraining from drug and alcohol, or total abstinence is viewed as the primary goal before other mental health issues can be addressed. Some psychiatrists will not prescribe the medications required to stabilize the very psychiatric symptoms presented because the patient is labeled as a “substance abuser”. What often occurs here is the individual suffering from their mental illness continues to use their substance of choice in an attempt to stabilize their mood or symptoms in the absence of a more constructive medically supervised pharmacological treatment.

While there are medical concerns, liabilities and risks involved when treating individuals with complicated presentations, medical precautions can be taken in order to safely medicate the psychiatric symptoms. This would then enable the individual to attain sufficient symptom relief in order to positively utilize the counseling and other treatments.

Dual Disorders

Some treatment providers are embracing the concept that individuals suffering from more than one disorder require an integrated treatment approach. Terms commonly used to describe individuals experiencing both psychiatric as well as substance abuse problems include: “Dual disorders”, “Co-Occurring Disorders”, “MICA” (Mentally Ill Chemical Abusers, and CAMI (Chemical Abusing Mentally Ill). There even exists a 12 Step self-help group to address this issue known as “Double Trouble”.

Optimal treatment for co-occurring disorders embraces what is called a “Harm Reduction” approach to recovery. With this philosophy it is recognized that recovery is an ongoing process where one may anticipate success, real life setbacks, possible relapse and then new goal attainment. A commitment to treating each individual and their families with an integrated treatment approach; is essential; one that is based in their individualized needs and choices so that they can best meet their goals.

###

Related Articles:
Susan Winston, LCSW, is a social worker. Ms. Winston has been practicing social work as a clinician and program director since 1978 in a variety of community based mental health and substance abuse programs.

An Overview of Suicide Risks among Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Questioning (LGBTQ) Youth

By Dave Reynolds, M.P.H. (Advocacy and Education Manager, The Trevor Project) and Phoenix Schneider, M.S.W. (Program Director, The Trevor Project)
Q: Are lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and questioning (LGBTQ) youth more likely to attempt suicide than other youth, and if so, why?
Numerous research studies have shown that LGBTQ youth are more likely to think about and attempt suicide than their heterosexual peers. According to the Massachusetts Youth Risk Behavior Survey, LGBTQ youth are up to four times more likely to attempt suicide than their heterosexual peers (2007). These findings are confirmed by numerous non-government research studies, many of which actually find the risk among sexual minority youth to be higher (selected research: Bradford JB – J Consult and Clin Psych 1994;62(2):228-242; D'Augelli AR – Suicide and Life Threatening Behav 2001;31:250-264; Paul JP – AJPH 2002;92(8):1338-1345; Silenzio VMB – AJPH 2007;97:2017-2019).
Nearly half of young transgender people have seriously thought about taking their lives and one-quarter have reported attempting suicide (Grossman AH, D'Augelli AR – Suicide and Life Threatening Behav 2007;37(5):527-537). Questioning youth, or those who are less certain of their sexual orientations, report experiencing thoughts of depression or suicide at even higher levels than their heterosexual or openly LGBT-identified peers (Poteat VP – J Consult and Clin Psych 2009;77(1):196-201).
This research can be shocking to those who are not acquainted with the disproportionate burden of mental illness that falls on LGBTQ young people, but it is also important to stress that these negative mental health outcomes are not a product of identifying as LGBT. Rather, the increased risk for suicide is a reaction to the negative and non-affirming languages and behaviors that so many sexual minority youth experience in their homes, schools, communities and religious institutions.
Q: Are shy or isolated LGBTQ youth more likely to have suicidal thoughts than LGBTQ youth growing up in metropolitan areas like New York City?
Our colleagues at the Gay, Lesbian and Straight Education Network (GLSEN) recently released a report in the Journal of Youth and Adolescence that found more bullying and harassment of young people related to sexual orientation or gender identity/expression in rural areas than in suburban or urban locations. These higher levels of harassment were also experienced by LGBTQ youth in communities where poverty is high and education levels are low (Kosciw JG – J Youth Adole 2009;38(7)L:976-988).
Numerous research studies have also shown a strong link between experiencing bullying related to one's perceived sexual orientation or gender identity and the increased risk for suicide among young people. To speak to these points, two-thirds of callers to The Trevor Helpline reach out to us from non-urban areas, and in states like New York and California, more than 80% and 90% (respectively) call us from outside major metropolitan areas.
Major cities like New York City or Los Angeles have many more resources available to LGBTQ young people than rural areas, so that can help to alleviate isolation for some. There are likely to be more mental health services, community centers and youth organizations as well. However, we know that young LGBTQ people are struggling in locations all across the country. Therefore, it's not accurate to definitively state that it's "easier" to identify as LGBTQ in a larger city.
Q: Are parents from some ethnic groups more likely to reject their LGBTQ children than others?
There are some research studies looking at the sexual identity development of LGBTQ young persons of color, but there is still a pressing need for more. Recent research has shown that LGBTQ youth who reporthigher levels of family rejection related to their sexuality are up to nine times more likely to report having attempted suicide, six timesmore likely to report high levels of depression and more than three times morelikely to use illegal drugs. They are also three times more likely to reporthaving engaged in unprotected sexual intercourse, when compared withpeers that reported no or low levels of familyrejection. Latino men reported the highest number of negativefamily reactions to their sexual orientation in adolescence (Ryan C – Peds 2009;123(1):346-352).
Q: Are LGBTQ youth who attempt suicide usually under the influence of alcohol or other drugs during the attempt?
Far too many LGBTQ youth struggle with isolation and rejection from their families, friends, schools, communities and religious institutions. A large percentage of these young people will then turn to drugs and alcohol – a huge risk factor for attempting suicide.
Additionally, youth today, LGBTQ and otherwise, are increasingly misusing prescription medicines – both to cope and also as a means for a suicide attempt. Surveillance data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) find that one-third of all suicide victims have alcohol in their systems at the time of death, and another one-fifth have opiates in their systems (2006). No data exists that can provide the sexual orientation or gender identity of suicide victims, but there is research regarding the use of drugs and alcohol among LGBTQ youth.
A recent study found that when compared with their heterosexual peers, youthidentifying as sexual minorities report having initiatedalcohol use at younger ages. Initiating alcohol use at younger ages among sexual minority youth significantlycontributes to elevated risks of binge drinking, and the findings suggest that disparities in alcoholuse among youth with a minority sexual orientation emerge inearly adolescence and persist into young adulthood (Corliss, HL – Arch Ped & Adole Med 2008;162(11):1071-1078). Further, questioning youth who are less certain of their sexual orientations, report even higher levels of substance abuse than their heterosexual or openly LGBT-identified peers (Poteat VP – J Consult and Clin Psych 2009;77(1):196-201). Recalling that substance abuse is a major risk factor in attempting suicide, and the increased risk for substance abuse among LGBTQ youth is a huge consideration in suicide prevention efforts among that group.
Q: What services are available to help these young people?
Aside from The Trevor Project's programs, there are some other resources for LGBTQ youth that social workers and service providers should know about it. For middle and high schools across the nation, the Gay, Lesbian, Straight Education Network, GLSEN, (www.GLSEN.org) provides resources for students and educators alike to make their schools safer and healthier places for sexual minority youth. GSA Network (www.GSANetwork.org) also works to make schools safer in the state of California. Campus Pride (www.CampusPride.org) is a similar advocacy and education organization that focuses its efforts on college campuses nationwide. Given the link between being the victim of sexual orientation and gender violence with the increased risk for making a suicide attempt, these organizations do critical work.
For young transgender people or those that might be struggling with issues around gender identity, there is Trans Youth Family Allies, TYFA, (www.ImaTYFA.org). With a mission of promoting education and eliminating harassment, TYFA works nationwide to ensure that more services and support are available to young people who have specific needs related to gender identity and expression. Parents, Family and Friends of Lesbians and Gays (PFLAG) also has support and information available to help young transgender people; it is available through their PFLAG Transgender Network at http://community.pflag.org/Page.aspx?pid=380.
For young people who may be unsure of their sexuality and/or gender identity or who have questions on how to "come out," www.OutProud.org has online information on all of these topics to help navigate these tough waters. There is also a GLBT National Youth Talkline for non-crisis issues, and it is staffed by trained volunteers at 1.800.246.7743 in the evenings every night. There are also valuable resource databases for the local level available both at www.TheTrevorProject.org under "Suicide Resources" as well as the GLBT National Help Center who in addition to the Youth Talkline also offers online peer-support chat. Their services are accessible at www.GLBTNationalHelpCenter.org.

###

Related Articles: